Fountain Menu



Homemade Ice Cream

Small Batches, churned in our own kitchen.

  • Vanilla Bean
  • Belgian Chocolate
  • Strawberry
  • Butter Pecan
  • Coconut Almond Chocolate Chip
  • Mint Chocolate Chip
  • Cookies & Cream
  • Coffee
  • Salted French Caramel
  • Bananas Foster

Refreshing Alternatives

  • Vegan Vanilla Bean Ice Cream
  • Vegan Dark Chocolate Ice Cream
  • No Sugar Added Vanilla Ice Cream
  • Seasonal Sorbet


Scoops & Cones

  • Traditional Cone or Cup
  • Homemade Waffle Cone
  • Chocolate-Dipped Waffle Cone
  • Hand-Packed Pints


Fountain Specialties

Ice Cream Sodas
Your favorite fountain-syrup flavor, carbonated water, and vanilla ice cream

Barrel Floats
Your choice of Sweet Moses Root Beer or Coke, topped with vanilla ice cream


Milk Shakes & Malts

Fountain syrup, acid phosphate, and ice cold carbonated water

We feature over 15 fountain syrup flavors – all made with pure cane sugar. Mix two and create your own.



  • Regular Classic
  • Double Classic

Both made with your favorite flavor, one topping, whipped cream and a cherry

  • Turtle Sundae
  • Banana Split
  • Brownie Sundae
  • Tin Roof


Hot fudge and caramel sauces are kettle-cooked right in our kitchen. There's nothing like them! All sundaes include whipped cream and a cherry



Signature Sundaes

Bob Feller Ballpark Sundae
Salted French Caramel ice cream topped with hot fudge, homemade caramel corn and Spanish peanuts

The Mount Carmel
Vanilla ice cream piled high with salted pistachios, warm homemade caramel and candy sprinkles

Shoreway Sundae
Coffee ice cream topped with hot fudge, toffee pieces and almonds

The Gordon Square
A large homemade brownie covered with Bananas Foster ice cream, topped with warm caramel and hot fudge

The Terminal Tower
Ten scoops of ice cream—one scoop of each classic flavor—build the foundation for this impressive edifice. The tower is completed with five toppings, almonds, pecans, sprinkles and more.


Pharmacy-Era Soda Fountain Drinks

Forgotten favorites from the golden age of the soda fountain.


 For the entire menu and pricing, download the menu PDF here.